Powerful hurricanes leave a lasting legacy, and in Puerto Rico humans are not the only ones devastated by storms such as last year’s Hurricane Maria. UConn professor of ecology and evolutionary biology Michael Willig is part of an international team that has spent the past 30 years studying elements of the ecosystem in hurricane-prone Puerto Rico, and how that ecosystem responds to weather-driven disturbances.
The team’s study is part of a National Science Foundation program called Long-Term Ecological Research (LTER). Each summer over the past few decades, members of the team have traveled to the study site to run experiments and make observations. Some summers have followed a quiet year weather-wise, and in other years the ecosystem has been in ‘recovery mode’ following a storm or drought.
During the study, Willig has documented population data and number of species for invertebrates, such as snails. While he has noticed decreases in snail populations after hurricanes over the years, nothing was as striking as the drop in numbers after Maria hit. When the researchers compared recently collected data to those collected after Hurricane Georges in 1998, they found a 60 per cent decrease in the total snail population caused by Maria – a 20 per cent larger decrease than after Georges.
“We saw changes in the abundances of species and loss of species,” he says. “Overall, things were much worse with Maria than with Georges.”
Among many other questions the researchers are seeking to answer, how will already rare snail populations recover after being heavily reduced by Hurricane Maria? And if snails are impacted so severely by these storms, what does this mean for the rest of the ecosystem?
This precipitous decrease and the ability to compare data over such a long period of time illustrates the importance of long-term studies like Willig’s.
Getting the full story
Imagine that an ecosystem is like a movie. Watching five minutes of a movie may give the viewer a good idea of what is happening but not a full understanding of the story or characters. Willig uses this analogy to underpin the significance of long-term ecological research.
When ecologists are interested in studying the story of an ecosystem, they may study one character for a year or two, and then have to extrapolate the rest of the story, Willig says. “With LTER, we get the long-term view from a diversity of perspectives, and can really investigate how the plot unravels.”
The aim of the LTER Program is to study species interactions and ecosystem processes over time in the rain forests in the Luquillo Mountains of Puerto Rico. In keeping with the analogy, storm-generated disturbances are like “plot twists” – radical changes in the direction or expected outcome of the plot – that drive species interactions over time.
Willig says species on Caribbean islands such as Puerto Rico have evolved to cope with hurricanes. Historically, one major storm would make landfall in the forest every 30 years or so. Yet these plot twists are becoming more frequent and more intense.
When the team first started studies at this site, it hadn’t experienced a major hurricane in more than 30 years. The first they witnessed was Hugo in 1989, and in the 30 years since then, there have been four major hurricanes.
Part of the research for the LTER Program involves studying biotic responses to increasingly challenging disturbances, and trying to understand how the biota will respond if climatic predictions are correct and the frequency of very intense hurricanes increases and the instances of extended droughts increase as well.
How will the story hold up if, as in the case of the snails, 60 percent of the characters are removed?
Aftermath of a plot twist
Snails are among the species that play a critical role in the recovery process after a major disturbance. Along with some frog and other gastropod (slug or snail) species, they proliferate in the debris ripped from trees that settles on the forest floor following a storm.
While frogs take refuge and breed in the debris, the gastropods clear the detritus and enhance the recycling of critical nutrients. Both species flourish in the destruction caused by a hurricane. But once the debris clears, their numbers decline, and other species become important.
If the data were only collected at isolated points in time, this ebb and flow would be missed.
Willig has two sayings he likes to refer to, one is that it is important for ecologists to be at the right place at the right time. More importantly, he says, “To get the full picture, it’s really about being at the right place all the time.”
How the forest will continue to cope if the hurricanes disrupt the area more frequently is a question that will only be answered with time – and long-term research.
The multidisciplinary team, which over the years has included around 40 UConn students, includes five principal investigators from different institutions, including most recently the University of Puerto Rico (Jess Zimmerman and Nick Brokaw), the University of California, Berkeley (Whendee Silver), the International Institute of Tropical Forestry (Grizelle Gonzalez), and UConn (Michael Willig). Current research is supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation (# DEB-1546686). The project will soon be in its sixth round of funding.